Why one of them will be on the cover: Because if there's a product to pitch, it seems like Peyton is the NFL's go-to guy. Then again, Peyton once told me: "If you can't actually play in a real game, I think 'NFL Fever 2004' brings you closer than anything else can." And we all know how that turned out (that quote never gets old, by the way). If only Eli was on the cover last year, we could have blamed the whole Plax shooting on collateral damage from the curse.